5 Responses to “Robert Crumb – A Critical Study”

1. J. Goodman Says:
   March 1st, 2010 at 1:56 am

   Having liked other volumes in this series pertaining to films, I held out hope that this tome would be a useful one in defining the career of Robert Crumb…Alas, I cannot recommend this book. Basically, my main problem with this book is the lack of illustrations. Without them the reviews of the various strips Crumb has created come off as something akin to a book report on comics…What’s the point? Just go out and find the comic. All of the comics reviewed are in print, and frankly the $6.95 would be better spent on the works themselves. There are many typos within the book making some sentences read awkward and hard to figure out…Dates for publications are not always correct, and the book feels as if it could have used a proofreader. On a positive note, it does include a new interview with R. Crumb conducted by mail which does shine some new light on what he’s been up to, but if you’ve seen the Crumb Documentary and read the R. Crumb Coffee table book, then this book is pretty redundant…If you haven’t done the above, put the money you’d spend on this thin volume towards those two items for a much better overview of “The Works Of Crumb”. Sorry Mr. Holm, but I do look forward to your anthology of Crumb Interviews mentioned on the back cover…That will probably be more worth it.
   Rating: 2 / 5

2. Chris Ward Says:
   March 1st, 2010 at 3:20 am

   Mr. Holm really needed an editor for this shapeless mess. It dabbles in biography and bibliography and manages to gradually become a series of reviews of several Crumb publications (seemingly randomly selected), but if you know anything about Crumb to begin with, you don’t need this book. I found it slapdash and frustrating– but it did drive me back to the Crumb comix and collections in my basement, so I guess I should be forgiving….
   Rating: 3 / 5

3. Kerry Walters Says:
   March 1st, 2010 at 3:36 am

   It amazes (and dismays) me that there’s no serious secondary work on the art of R. Crumb. He’s one of the most important artistic voices to come out of late twentieth-century America. His satiric comix offer social criticism, invite us to rethink sexual and racial taboos, and delight us with their skillful and beautiful artwork. Crumb’s influence on a whole generation of artists, literati, musicians, cultural commentators, and ordinary guys like me is undisputed. Yet the scholars insist on ignoring him, and this is bothersome.

   That’s why D.K. Holm’s little book is refreshing, even though inadequate. It’s relatively up to date, appearing merely five years ago, and ends with a 2002 interview with Crumb (which is also reprinted in Holm’s R. Crumb: Conversations, University of Mississippi Press). Moreover, the book provides a decent overview of Crumb’s life and career, although curiously the biographical chapters get thinner as the book progresses and Crumb ages; you’d think just the opposite ought to happen. Finally, Holm offers pretty good synopses of some of Crumb’s most pivotal work, including (somewhat uncritical) evaluations of it. Along the way, Holm briefly discusses some of the influences on Crumb, a few of the themes in his work, and the phases his work has gone through: from greeting card stuff to the LSD-inspired breakthrough to the years of despair, to the move toward realism to the latest (although only mentioned) “mystic” stage.

   All this is to the good, and Holm is to be thanked. But it’s all too brief, too impressionistic, too sketchy. What we really need is someone (Robert Hughes, perhaps?) either to put together a collection of critical essays on Crumb the artist/thinker/iconoclast, or to write a booklength critical examination of him. But until that time comes, Holm’s little book is at least something.
   Rating: 4 / 5

4. Anonymous Says:
   March 1st, 2010 at 5:21 am

   Reading about this notoriously “sexist” and “racist” comic book artist, I was gratified by Holm’s unpacking of these controversies in terse prose, while supplying abundant facts in fleshing out Crumb’s work and fascinating story. This thin paperback gets a lot covered and defends Crumb’s artistic and life choices without suffering from sycophantic dribbling. Bravo!
   Rating: 5 / 5

5. MorrisTheKat Says:
   March 1st, 2010 at 7:27 am

   I can’t imagine a better book for becoming acquainted with one of our national treasures. I’d read others of the Pocket Essentials series, and this is one of the best. For those looking for fully-illustrated narratives, they’d best look elsewhere. But bang-for-the-buck’ers (like me) are well served. Especially liked the interview.
   Rating: 5 / 5

Leave a Reply

Name (required)

Mail (will not be published) (required)

Website

CAPTCHA Code

---

Pin-Up Art

1000 Pin-Up Girls (25th Anniversary Special Edtn)
Amazon Price: $10.19
Customer Review: I purchased this book to help design a tattoo. It was VERY helpful, and now it makes for a nice coffee-table book! There are a few repeats of photos in this book, but that's because they're from different magazine covers, or different months.
 
Pin-up Artist
by Ignacio Noe
Amazon Price: $9.44
 
The Great American Pin-Up (Jumbo Series)
by Charles G Martignette Dr.
Amazon Price:
Customer Review: This is a fantastic book; the essays are substantive and very informative about not only the artists but about the period they were working in, distinctions of high and low art, etc. The pictures are excellent quality and profuse throughout. An inc...
 
Girls on Top! the Pin-Up Art of Matt Dixon
by Matt Dixon
Amazon Price: $10.17
Customer Review: I've seen Matt Dixon's art in a number of other venues previous to this book (including the art tutorial book Fantasy Artist's Figure Drawing Bible: Ready-to-Draw Characters and Step-by-Step Rendering Techniques) which he wrote and illustrated and, h...
 
The Pin-up Art of Dan DeCarlo
by Dan DeCarlo
Amazon Price: $16.20
Customer Review: Having always been a fan of Betty and Veronica (I'm more of a Veronica type myself), I was happily surprised to see the release of this book. Mr. DeCarlo's art is a great romp through thrugh the golden age of comic pin ups. It's a treasure for anyone...
 

---

News about Pin-up Art

Ikea: Home is where the art is 31 Aug 2010 at 11:26pm
Affordable art for the home used to mean an Athena poster. Famously, there was the image of a handsome male model holding a baby, while teenage boys lusted after the tennis girl, photographed resting a hand on her bare bottom. It was fun and it was cheesy. Millions of us pinned these posters to our bedroom walls.
Magazine Covers of the Year: What's Good, What's Bad, What's Puzzling 2 Sep 2010 at 7:14pm
Assessing the spectacular?and peculiar?nominations for the annual awards New York - Lady Gaga - Rolling Stone - Amazon.com - American Society of Magazine Editors
The naked truth about nude art 31 Aug 2010 at 6:12pm
The painting was pretty innocuous in Jane Everett?s mind.