Watchmen Graphic Novel Should be Left a Comic Book
Back in 1986, writer Alan Moore and artist Dave Gibbons formulated a mystery based on the Cold War, wherein the threat of nuclear warfare is an imminent fear. The story explored the possibility that superheroes existed in the 1940s. And the Watchmen were born...
And in this setting of the Watchmen graphic novel, superheroes are roughly classified into two. They are either working for the government, donning their suits while on retainer and paid by people’s taxes, or they are outlawed. Most superheroes not working for the government have decided to embark on other productive endeavors like business, and leave crime-fighting and costume-wearing behind. Some continue to be heroes, but are considered as fugitives, thanks to the law that was passed outlawing superheroes.
Creator Alan Moore cannot be blamed for wanting his art to remain in the chosen medium it was created. Not only due to the huge differences between reading a comic book and watching a film, but also because of the previous experiences he has had with his publisher and the process of converting his work from paper to film.
Initially, he thought that separating himself from the process of converting his work to a movie would turn out fine. Moore admits that he was wrong about distancing himself. The latest of his work to be released as a movie is the Watchmen graphic novel.
“The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen,” one of Moore’s works, was also adapted into film. He distanced himself from the process, feeling that as long as he didn’t see any of the film and had nothing to do with it, everything would be fine.
He was fairly surprised when producer Martin Poll and writer Larry Cohen filed a law suit against 20th Century Fox for alleged plagiarism. They claim that their script - yet to be produced - was copied. Indeed, the two scripts bore many similarities, but these were elements added to the film and were not in any way found in Moore’s comics.
Due to the lawsuit, Alan Moore had to testify in a deposition. The experience, he described, was shockingly painful. As if the misery was not enough, Fox settled the case, signaling to Moore that it was an admission of guilt, something he stated he had no involvement in.
When “V for Vendetta” was made into a film, producer Joel Silver stated to the press that fellow producer Larry Wachowski had talked with Alan Moore, and that Moore was excited about the project. But according to Moore, he adamantly refused to be part of anything with films, and still wasn’t interested in Hollywood.
Alan Moore wanted a public retraction and an apology. While he got an apology from Silver, who appears had also been deceived by Wachowski, there never was a public retraction.
Aside from this, Moore claims that the comic book was specifically about anarchy and fascism. Nowhere in the movie was these two things even seen or mentioned. Clearly, the adaptation of the comic book into a film reinvents Moore’s work into something totally different, something Moore would have not created and would definitely not want to be credited with.
The Watchmen graphic novel became the latest of Moore's being adapted into a film, and was released in 2009. And anyone who has read the graphic novel and seen the film knows that the film was yucky to say the least.
Due to the lack of ability of Hollywood to translate his works into films that fairly reflect his work, it is understandable the reluctance and displeasure expressed by Alan Moore regarding film adaptations. It is bad enough that he doesn’t get paid for his work, he is also stuck with his name attached to work inherently at odds with what and who Alan Moore is.
If you haven't read Watchmen, you have a treat in store, but read before you try watching the film...
Watchmen Graphic Novel Should Have been Left a Comic Book related articles from the blogosphere...
REVIEW: Watchmen, Alan Moore (Graphic Novel Week #3) ~ Katie M ...
This is the third day of Graphic Novel Week (although, technically, it should be the fourth...), and I'm going to be talking about arguably the most famous graphic novel ever written: Watchmen. While a lot of graphic novels have been ...
Publish Date: 11/04/2010 9:40
http://katiemstout.blogspot.com/2010/11/review-watchmen-alan-moore-graphic.html
Watchmen: The Graphic Novel, the Movie and Adaptation
The Watchmen graphic novel is sublime. It's film adaptation is one of the more faithful that I've seen, and it's very entertaining. But it didn't move me. I am truly at a loss to describe why. I don't think it's because it became more ...
Publish Date: 11/02/2010 14:08
http://pharoahphobia.blogspot.com/2010/11/watchmen-graphic-novel-movie-and.html
Why Do Graphic Novel Adaptations Of Popular Novels Usually Suck ...
There's no sense of a world being shown or a story told. Compare that with Asterios Polyp where every color matters or Watchmen's long comic-ending document “excerpts” from things in the graphic novel. It just looks like laziness to me. ...
Publish Date: 11/01/2010 0:01
http://dreamsandspeculation.com/2010/11/01/why-do-graphic-novel-adaptations-of-popular-novels-usually-suck/
Watchmen: Graphic Novel vs. Movie comparison
Comparing shots from the Watchmen trailer to Alan Moore's graphic novel.
